Before You Order the Fish, Read This

Fish is a tricky one when it comes to healthy eating.

For decades, it's been sold as a health food: full of omega-3s, lean protein, and good for your heart. Eating fish twice a week has been standard advice for a long time.

But the way fish gets to our plates has changed a lot in the last fifty years, and the research is more mixed than that simple advice makes it sound.

Here's what's worth knowing.

Why fish got its healthy reputation

Fish earned its reputation mostly because of two omega-3 fats, EPA and DHA. They're linked to a healthier heart and brain, less inflammation, and a baby's healthy growth during pregnancy.

Those benefits are real, and the research behind them is strong. So the question isn't whether omega-3s matter. It's where they come from, and whether fish is the only way to get them.

Where omega-3s really come from

Here's something most people don't know: fish don't make omega-3s. Tiny algae at the bottom of the ocean food chain do. Fish get them by eating the algae, or by eating smaller fish that did. So fish are really just passing along nutrients that started in algae.

Omega-3 supplements made from algae are easy to find now, and they give you EPA and DHA straight from the source. Studies show your body absorbs algae omega-3s about as well as fish oil. If you want the benefits without the downsides of fish, they're a well-studied option.

Flaxseed, chia seeds, walnuts, and hemp seeds have a different omega-3 called ALA. Your body can turn some ALA into EPA and DHA, but not much. That's why an algae supplement is the more reliable choice if you don't eat fish at all.

What about mercury?

Mercury builds up as it moves up the food chain. When a fish eats smaller fish, it takes on the mercury from all of them. So the bigger the fish and the longer it lives, the more mercury it usually carries.

The FDA and EPA tell pregnant women, women who may become pregnant, nursing mothers, and young children to skip high-mercury fish completely, including shark, swordfish, king mackerel, and tilefish. They suggest two or three servings a week of lower-mercury fish instead. That advice is there because mercury can harm a developing brain.

For most other adults, eating low-mercury fish in moderation is considered safe. Still, it's good to know about mercury, especially if you eat fish several times a week or often choose the bigger kinds.

Is it sustainable?

Fish around the world are under a lot of pressure. The UN Food and Agriculture Organization reports that more than a third of the world's fish stocks are being overfished. Other sea life caught by accident, ocean floors torn up by trawling nets, and pollution from fish farms are real problems too.

If stewardship is part of how you think about food, this matters too, right alongside your own health.

So what does this mean for you?

Eating fish now and then isn't harmful for most healthy adults. But the research shows that what's good about fish is really the omega-3s, and you can get those other ways. And the downsides, like mercury, overfishing, and how industrial fishing works, are real enough to keep in mind.

If you do eat fish, current advice is to choose lower-mercury kinds like salmon, sardines, trout, and herring, and to buy from sustainable sources when you can.

If you're eating more plants, or thinking about cutting back on fish or giving it up, you can still get what you need. An algae omega-3 supplement covers EPA and DHA. A variety of whole plant foods covers protein, zinc, and most of the rest. For iodine, use iodized salt or eat a little seaweed, since most plant foods don't have much.

The Vegan People Plant Pantry has plenty of whole plant foods with the nutrients people usually eat fish for, each explained in plain language.

Explore the Plant Pantry at veganpeople.net/plantpantry →

Sources: FDA and EPA fish consumption advisories. UN Food and Agriculture Organization. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition. Nutrients journal, algal omega-3 bioavailability research.

Previous
Previous

The Loneliness Nobody Talks About in the Wellness Conversation

Next
Next

Your Gut Does More Than You Think. Here’s What Feeds It.